Can an employer (current or prospective) discriminate against you if you've
filed for a
Chapter 7 bankruptcy or a
Chapter 13 bankruptcy? This is a question we get quite often. It is the shared concern
of people currently employed and considering filing bankruptcy, and the
currently unemployed person considering filing for bankruptcy, but who
has the very obvious hope of becoming employed in the future. There are
really two separate answers to this question; one for governmental employers
and one for private employers. Section 525(a) of the Bankruptcy Code addresses
discrimination by governmental employers, and Section 525(b) addresses
discrimination by private employers.
A reading of these two sections will reveal that both Section 525(a), relating
to governmental employers, and 525(b), dealing with private employers,
contain language that prohibits the discrimination of
current employees
on the basis of a bankruptcy filing. Unfortunately, however, only Section
525(a) (again, relating only to governmental employers) includes the language
"...deny employment to..." which prohibits the discrimination of
prospective employees
on the basis of a bankruptcy filing. What does this mean? Well...since
Section 525(b) contains no language prohibiting the discrimination of
prospective employees
, this means that private employers can discriminate against job applicants
on the basis of a bankruptcy filing. This position was recently upheld
by a U.S. District Court in
Rea v. Federated Investors
, 2010 WL 370334 (W.D. Penn. Jan. 29, 2010).
In
Rea v. Federated Investors
, the Plaintiff was denied employment after the prospective employer (a
private employer) reviewed the Plaintiff's credit report and noted
a 2002 bankruptcy discharge. The Plaintiff was subsequently denied employment
by Defendant, and Plaintiff sued on the basis of discrimination. In dismissing
Plaintiff's case, the Court noted that while Section 525(a) contains
language that forbids a governmental employer from denying employment
based upon a bankruptcy filing, Section 525(b) does not, and only forbids
a private employer from terminating existing employment on the basis of
a bankruptcy filing. The Court noted that Congress must have had a reason
for omitting the language "deny employment to" from Section
525(b), and therefore reasoned that private employers may discriminate
against a prospective employee based upon a Chapter 7 or Chapter 13 bankruptcy.